I voted for the Brown Derby, Sci Fi and Mama Melrose's. My comments on Sci Fi are the same as yours MBabe, so I won't repeat them.
Resturant: The Hollywood Brown Derby (please note there is no "and" in the name)
Atmosphere: Classic Hollywood! Cool caricatures on the walls.
Food Rating: Excellent!
Comments: The Brown Derby has the distinction of being the only WDW restaurant we have eaten at on every trip. I love this place. It's got wonderful service and excellent food....GRAPEFRUIT CAKE!!!!!!! I gotta got my fix of this cake. Love it! If you think this place is "too pricey," then I would suggest splitting appetizers/entrees/desserts. DH and I do this frequently and we fill up.
Resturant: Mama Melrose's
Atmosphere: I really don't remember the decor, other than a typical Italian styled place.
Food Rating: Very Good
Comments: Mama Melrose's...it was pretty good the night we went. We were pleasantly surprised. We couldn't get into the FDP with the Brown Derby and settled on Mama Melrose's. The reason I voted for it is...BELLINIS!!! I discovered this drink at Palo on the Disney Wonder, and discovered it again two days later at Mama Melrose's. They also have some good breads, which is a must for a carbohydrate lover like myself. I never met a carbohydrate I didn't love.
MGM and Epcot are two parks I shy away from counter service and focus on table service restaurants.