Mickey's Christmas Party vs. Halloween Party?

Should I go to WDW during Mickey's Not So Scary Halloween Party or Mickey's Very Merry Christmas Party?

After going to both in various years, I tend to prefer MNSSHP to MVMCP.

I enjoy both parties but I guess I enjoy MNSSHP a little more. I love the music, parade and of course getting to dress up.

I would probably like the Halloween party more, but would love all th eparks in Christmas decorations. Halloween gets my vote.

I have been to both in recent years. The Halloween party was a lot more fun.

I was at the Christmas party at the beginning of December in 2008. I found the crowds to be absolutely crushing. I think there were a lot of people there that didn't pay. It was cold, so everyone had jackets on. I'm not sure if there was a lot of checking for wristbands. This really bothered me about the Christmas party. Although, I did enjoy the castle stage show and the snow on Main St.

I attended the Halloween party the end of September in 2007. I felt that castmembers did a much better job of herding people out without wristbands. I also really, really enjoyed Hallowishes and the parade. My little one really enjoyed the trick-or-treating. In my opinion, the Halloween party is definitely worth the extra money.

Although the Christmas party is fun ---- I love, love, LOVE the Halloween party!!

The decorations are amazing, trick-or-treating is fun, and the costumes that people think of are out of this world!!

The fireworks are some of the best I have ever seen in the park, the parade is my all time favorite ---- but the best thing of the night is the Headless Horseman racing down the street!! That alone is worth the price of admission!

So question...During the Christmas season can you only see Wishes if you have tickets to the very merry christmas party?

Yes you can see the fireworks/parades at the end of the park just make sure you have the wristband on for when they kick out the reg. guests. (My family did it for the Halloween party)

As for the Forum Topic. I SOOOO like MNSSHP much better then MVMCP.
MVMCP I had watered-down not-so-hot coco, and a really bad tasting cookie.
MNSSHP you get endless amounts of candy, and dress-up with out looking like a freak.

plus the fireworks/parades are way cooler for Halloween then X-mas.

We went to the Halloween party last year for the first time and loved it!

We have done both and enjoyed the Halloween Party much, much more.

Have only done MVMCP, so that is my favorite, so far...

I've done both (and will be doing both this year). But I prefer mnsshp over mvmcp.

I think they both are completely equal and have the perfect setting for the season... but due to the fact that I love christmas wayyyy too much (christmas 365/366) (and the fact that you probably will do the other holiday activites in the other parks) i'd pick MVMCP.

I loved Mickey's Not So Scary Halloween Party when I went with my fiancee last year.

Not So Scary Hands Down